How to Stay Sane in a House of Homicidal Eccentrics: Mortimer Brewster in Arsenic and Old Lace

Frank Capra’s Arsenic and Old Lace opens on a note of cheerful romance and playful banter, yet it doesn’t take long for the story to tip into murder and madness. At the heart of it all stands Mortimer Brewster, played by Cary Grant with a remarkable blend of exasperation and comic grace. Grant’s rapid shifts—an irreverent one-liner here, a full-bodied recoil in horror there—draw us into Mortimer’s bewildering role as both observer and reluctant participant in his family’s deadly secrets. This performance underscores just how unusual Mortimer is as a protagonist: he navigates genuine moral turmoil while trapped in a comedy of terrors.

Initially, Mortimer seems like any other well-mannered fiancé, eager to introduce his beloved Elaine to his dear aunts, Abby and Martha. It’s not until he discovers they’ve been poisoning lonely boarders—under the delusion that they’re actually doing these men a kindness—that he grasps the depth of his predicament. Far from a simple black-and-white horror, the aunts’ lethal benevolence leaves him reeling between shock and empathy. He knows their actions are reprehensible, but he also senses they’re propelled by a genuine, if wildly misguided, compassion. This duality makes Mortimer’s dilemma acutely personal: he cannot simply denounce two women who have always treated him with love.

Complicating the situation further is his brother Jonathan, whose brand of cruelty has none of the aunts’ mistaken altruism. Jonathan embraces violence without remorse, forcing Mortimer to manage two distinct threats within the same household. Suddenly, the Brewster residence transforms into a theatrical stage, one Mortimer wishes he could exit. His background as a drama critic only heightens this discomfort: he sees the insane premise for what it is—something that would be absurdly funny if it weren’t happening in reality. That “meta-awareness” intensifies his panic, as each new twist reminds him just how unhinged this private show has become.

Yet Mortimer doesn’t walk away. In fact, his most unusual trait may be his decision to stay and juggle everyone’s safety. He knows turning in the aunts is the moral choice, yet his loyalty and genuine affection for them complicate any easy resolution. His internal struggle is less about whether murder is wrong—he’s certain it is—than about reconciling the monstrous act with the sweetness of the people committing it. This tug-of-war between love and ethical duty reveals an essential part of Mortimer’s character: he’s not blind to evil, but he’s also unwilling to abandon those he cares about, no matter how far they stray into darkness.

Teddy, the brother who believes he’s Theodore Roosevelt, adds another dimension to Mortimer’s burden. With Teddy digging “locks” for the Panama Canal in the cellar—essentially preparing graves for the aunts’ future victims—Mortimer finds himself covering up not just the murders, but the swirling chaos of an entire delusional ecosystem. His fiancée, Elaine, becomes collateral damage; her reasonable desire for a normal relationship collides with a reality more bizarre than anything Mortimer critiques in the theater.

Then comes the revelation that Mortimer isn’t actually a Brewster by blood, delivering him from the fear of inheriting any so-called “family madness.” At first glance, it seems like a tidy solution to his deepest anxieties—if he’s not one of them, he can’t be doomed to their fate. But this twist is more than a convenient escape hatch. It underscores how his true bond with the family has never been merely genetic. He’s chosen to shoulder their secrets and protect them all along, well before he realized his lineage wasn’t at stake. In a sense, the discovery highlights just how unusual Mortimer’s behavior really is: even once freed from blood ties, he remains tethered by loyalty, moral responsibility, and a stubborn faith that the situation can somehow be contained.

Cary Grant’s portrayal amplifies each frantic pivot Mortimer makes, from witty repartee to near-panic, culminating in comedic sequences that feel both exhausting and exhilarating. The camera often lingers on Mortimer’s wide-eyed reactions, as if inviting us to marvel at how he continues to stand firm in a house rattled by lethal secrets. In these moments, Grant’s performance lays bare the strangeness of Mortimer’s position: here is a man who perceives the folly around him more clearly than anyone else, yet cannot bring himself to blow the whistle. Instead, he orchestrates a precarious balance, hoping against hope that no more harm is done.

Ultimately, Mortimer is an unusual hero precisely because he never brandishes a sword of righteousness. He’s trapped in a moral labyrinth where love and murder collide, and he responds not with grand gestures but with frantic improvisation. His efforts to preserve his aunts’ safety—while reining in Jonathan’s malevolence—strip him of any illusion that he’s the stable center in a lunatic world. At the same time, that very unwillingness to abandon his family reveals a profound humanity beneath the comedic veneer. Mortimer Brewster may not be the typical leading man, but his predicament captures a rarely explored corner of the comedic psyche: what happens when you love people who commit unforgivable acts, yet can’t bear to see them suffer?
​
By the end of Arsenic and Old Lace, Mortimer emerges not as a champion of justice, but as a testament to how “normal” can bend without breaking, even in the face of murderous relatives and startling revelations. His unusual brand of loyalty—and his readiness to endure the absurd—makes him both an unlikely hero and a figure worth dissecting. In a household where poison is served with a smile, perhaps the strangest thing of all is that Mortimer stays, caring more about salvaging what’s left of love and sanity than about rushing to condemn. It’s this blend of compassion, desperation, and comedic horror that cements him as one of cinema’s most intriguing, if reluctant, guardians of a dangerously eccentric home.